BOTTOM
LINE: Visually
stunning, but flat in its narrative and story, “Alice In Wonderland”
demonstrates director Tim Burton’s flair for images if not
any sense of narrative depth or character.
THE
GOOD:
Going in to a Tim Burton movie you will know that at least visually
he will create something unique, rich and off-beat; “Alice
In Wonderland” is no exception to this rule. The fantastic
combination of computer animation, live action actors and presentation
in 3-D makes the world of Wonderland come to life in a way that
has not been seen before. The interaction between computer generated
and live action characters is seamless, and the impression you get
is of one image after another that resemble graphic art rather than
film. Being based on a popular and strong story, the film does well
in presenting Alice’s journey from a going from Point A to
Point B perspective. The film really shines in the visuals, production
design, costume and make-up. As light-hearted fare, “Alice
In Wonderland” makes for a somewhat entertaining film.
THE
BAD:
The film is flat from a narrative and character perspective. There
is no sense of drama or rhythm, as each sequence flows from one
point to the next with mechanical precision. It almost seems as
if Tim Burton has taken for granted that you know this story already
and instead plunges you straight in without much of a dramatic introduction.
He does change the story so Alice is now a late teen, but this hardly
matters as her story is essential still the same, despite the fact
that elements of both of the original novels have been combined
in to this story. In some ways it feels like a sequel, but it is
not, which adds to the lack of interesting drama. You feel as if
you have missed out on something in the story, something to hook
you in Alice’s original journey. As a result, the film is
enjoyable enough to watch, particularly from a visual perspective,
but there is no emotional or dramatic connection to be made with
it.